Black and White 5 Day Challenge :#2

Jamestown A 007      b &w_2576x1839

I chose this photo today to convert to black and white as I thought it had a sort of old world feeling. The children, especially the little girl, are dressed in the fashion from an earlier age, and I wonder if that is a picnic basket or is mother collecting something.

I don’t usually think landscapes look better in monochrome, so I am putting in the original to see what you think.

Jamestown A 007_3072x2304

I also cropped out the bushes on the right hand side to bring it more into line with the rule of thirds.

*****************

Gwennie of “Gwennie’s Garden” has invited me to join in. I love to visit Gwennie, her blog is filled with gorgeous photos of flowers and succulents from her garden and interspersed with stories of her travels. Well worth a visit.

There are only two rules for this challenge:

1. On 5 consecutive days, create a post using either a past or recent photo in B&W.
2. Each day invite another blog friend to join in the fun.

Today I would like to nominate Jude of “Travel Words to join in. Of course this is only if you have the time and want to.

Jude has travelled extensively and she takes us with her on her journeys in both words and photos. Not only does she do that but she hosts a “Bench Series” challenge and has a second blog devoted to her passion in plants, “The earth laughs in flowers”

Categories: 5 day b & w challenge, Australia, black and white, photos, post-a-day, rule of thirds, Weekly photo challenge | Tags: , , , , , | 42 Comments

Post navigation

42 thoughts on “Black and White 5 Day Challenge :#2

  1. Hi Pauline, I prefer this one in black and white. Love it.

    Like

  2. I think the black and white version is the best, too. I think it shows the play of light more somehow. I can see I am going to learn a lot form this challenge, Pauline.

    Like

  3. they are both awesome pictures !

    Like

  4. Mature people? What can Jack mean, Pauline? 🙂 We’re all young here. This is another ‘natural’ for black and white. Properly ‘old world’, but I wasn’t around then, honestly!

    Like

    • Of course we’re all “young” (at least in spirit!!!) Jo, that was our parents era (saying with tongue firmly in cheek) actually it was, I was a rock-n-roll teen not a flapper…

      Liked by 1 person

  5. This photo will take many on a trip down memory lain.
    Most mature people (oldies) will recall a scene like this.

    Liked by 1 person

  6. I can not make up my mind. One the one hand, I like the BW one because it looks old world. On the other hand, I like the colour one because it has brought sunshine to my wintery dark corner of the world.

    Like

    • Thank you for your comments, we are lucky to have digital images to play with, then we can have the best of both worlds. Pleased to bring you a slice of sunshine

      Liked by 1 person

  7. I like them both. They have very different feels. I’m doing this challenge, too. Fun, isn’t it?

    janet

    Like

  8. lovely picture !

    Like

  9. I love the B&W version, Pauline. It really does look from a bygone era. Beautiful reflections. 🙂

    Like

  10. Totally different effects in the two versions, but the reflections are the stars in both. B&W is far more evocative.

    Liked by 1 person

  11. Both versions work well. I love the colour version with the bushes (they frame the river). It has a painterly feel about it and the trees are very distinct. The black and white version looks as though it has come out of an old book – the light catches the family in this version.

    Thanks for the invite – I shall do my best!

    Like

  12. I like both versions but, what is interesting to me is that I see things in a distinctly different way with each version. In the color photo, the background building immediately draws attention and distracts focus from the river and trees (but I love the dress color). In the b & w, the building blends into the background, and the river, trees, and people become more important. I’m glad you included both for contrast.

    Like

    • That is a very interesting observation. I see what you mean, I hadn’t noticed it before, but yes the red of the bbq does jump out in the colour version, especially as it is so central, and then blends with the trees in the b&w.

      Liked by 1 person

  13. Sandra

    although it looks more atmospheric in B/W I think it has a look of a John Constable painting in colour, so I prefer the colour version.

    Liked by 1 person

  14. Jackie

    Always like the B&W images….

    Jackie Carroll |Compliance & Management Systems
    m +64 21 342766

    [Description: D:\TRANZLIQUID ADMIN\TEMPLATES\logo-tranzliquid.bmp]
    The bulk petroleum logistics experts
    Right product, right quantity, right tank – ON TIME- GUARANTEED!

    Web |www.tranzliquid.co.nz fb |facebook

    Like

  15. A great photo and agree it is even better in B&W. This is an excellent challenge. I am currently choosing some photos for an upcoming book and these have to be in B&W too. What has quickly become apparent is that some of the colour ones that in would have chosen do not look so good in B&W. Quite a challenge!

    Like

    • G’day Wilbur, I appreciate your feedback on the photo. I agree it is not easy to find colour photos that convert to b&w I spent a very interesting and pleasurable few hours searching through all my files trying different images for this challenge.
      Would you be interested in taking part in this 5 day challenge? If so I will nominate you tomorrow in my next post.

      Like

  16. I love both pictures but somehow the black and white does speak more to me in this case.

    Like

  17. I think it looks better in black and white, nostalgic, but I actually prefer the bushes, rule of thirds or not!

    Like

    • Now that is interesting . I couldn’t make my mind up about the crop so thought I would show a before and after. Thank you for the comment Gilly.

      Like

  18. I acutally like it better in black and white!

    Like

I love to receive comments, maybe we could start a conversation.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

Margaret Hall Fine Art

A WORLD OF COLOUR

Ally's Notebook

Thoughts To Share

I scrap 2

On Safari and More about photos and photography writing and life experiences....

A wonderful sheep

Navigating the creative seas

Curls n Skirls

del's sewing stuff

anotherdayinparadise

Travels in Paradise

poppytump@no4

Photography and Sketching ... Observations ...

wordsandimages

here, there and other places

Brizzy Mays Books and Bruschetta

Predominately Books But Other Stuff Too

The Eternal Traveller

Remembering past journeys, recording current trips and planning for the next one!

Womanseyeview's Blog

Nothing profound and a few of my photos

P.A. Moed

Creative Exploration in Words and Pictures

snippetsandsnaps

Potato Point and beyond

priorhouse blog

Photos, art - and a little bit of LIT.

Life is great

Despite its troubles

%d bloggers like this: